Skip to content

Search The Workout Digest

Heavier power cleans didn’t always produce more power in this review

You add weight to a power clean and the pull becomes more demanding. That is a heavier lift, but did you produce more power? A new review compared loads in power cleans and hang power cleans and found a broad high-power range, rather than one clear winning percentage.

The finding concerns power produced during test repetitions. It doesn’t identify the load that will build the most strength or power over months of training.

A man holding a barbell in the front-rack position with his knees bent.
Heavier power cleans didn’t always produce more power in this review © Binyamin Mellish / Pexels
Table of contents
  1. The higher load bands didn’t have a clear winner
  2. A training goal still has to guide the load
  3. A light bar can have a specific teaching job

The higher load bands didn’t have a clear winner

The November 2026 review pooled 14 studies and 197 experienced participants, mostly male. Researchers measured peak power using force plates, including body mass in the calculations. These measurements describe the lifter-and-bar system, rather than barbell-only power.

Loads above 40% of one-repetition maximum generally outperformed lighter loads. But comparisons among above-40%-to-70%, above-70%-to-85% and above-85% bands found no statistically significant advantage. That doesn’t prove every weight in those bands is equivalent.

The broad bands and selection of one peak-power observation per band could also conceal individual differences.

A training goal still has to guide the load

The NSCA’s weightlifting position statement distinguishes training that emphasizes force production from training that emphasizes movement velocity. Its programming discussion includes both heavier and lighter exercise-load combinations, selected for the athlete’s needs.

That gives heavier lifting a purpose beyond winning an immediate power comparison. A session intended to develop force-generating capacity and a session emphasizing fast movement can use different choices. The statement also stresses technical competency, relative strength, exercise complexity and the goal of the training phase.

Before changing your working weight, identify which of those qualities the session is meant to emphasize. Ask your coach whether today’s target is heavier force production, faster movement or learning the lift. The answer should help explain the load choice, rather than leaving you to assume that every extra plate improves every quality.

A light bar can have a specific teaching job

In a separate NSCA coaching article, strength and conditioning specialist Joe Cruz, MS, CSCS, describes starting with a light load so lifters can learn the movement and make adjustments. His approach increases weight or tempo once the required performance points are met.

Cruz also describes how individual mobility, coordination and awareness affect learning. His group-teaching progression can begin from higher positions before working toward the floor, depending on the lifter. It is one coaching approach, rather than a test showing that everyone should follow the same progression.

If you are still learning the movement, use that stage for technical feedback instead of treating a heavier bar as the answer to every difficulty. A coach can check the actual repetition, including the starting position and receive, before increasing its demands.

Our guide to hang and power clean names separates where the lift starts from how the bar is received. Make sure the intended movement is clear before discussing its load.